auth_basic and satisfy allowing all traffic

[daveyfx]

Hi all -

I'm having an issue trying to get auth_basic and satisfy directives working
in tandem.  If I use auth_basic/auth_basic_user_file on its own, I am
prompted for credentials as expected.  However, if I added the
satisfy/allow/deny directives above, it seems that ALL traffic is allowed in
without prompting for auth.

Here's how I have it.

    satisfy any;
    allow 38.103.XX.XXX/32;     # HQIP
    allow 38.118.XX.XXX/32;     # User VPN IP
    deny all;

    auth_basic "Site Restricted";
    auth_basic_user_file includes/htpasswd.site.dev.conf;

When I look though my access logs, I see the correct client IP as well.

nginx version is 1.10.1

Thank you for your help.

Dave

Posted at Nginx Forum: https://forum.nginx.org/read.php?2,273629,273629#msg-273629